apple chai-der pie (spiced black tea apple pie with streusel topping)


If yesterday’s pecan pie wasn’t enough, here’s another that you can prepare ahead of time and assemble on the day of baking!

I first learned to do apple pie at a workshop in downtown Durham, at Scratch Bakery. I’d been trying to do double-crust apple pie for a few weeks before but it was too much work so I gave up and decided to follow Phoebe Lawless’s method, covering the pie in streusel. The streusel itself is easy and you can really make it any way you want. Streusel is defined asn., a crumbly topping made from fat, flour, sugar, and nuts/spices, often cinnamon, used as a topping or filling for cakes”, so you can add oats, brown sugar, different types of flours, spices, and so on. I like the streusel combination I used here (flour, sugar, oats, butter, salt, and cinnamon) and I’ll end up using it fairly often, like for the pumpkin streusel muffins.


Coring, peeling, and chopping the apples by hand was a pain the first few times I made the pie, so I bought one of those old-fashioned hand-crank spiralizers: 3-in-one, cores, slices, and peels the apples all at once. And it looks cool, too.

That being said, sometimes the most tedious aspects of cooking or baking can also be the most relaxing. If you have plenty of time, the kitchen to yourself, a bottle of red wine (it has to be red wine because red wine is the best wine), and your favorite Spotify playlist (I like anything acoustic or morning-oriented, even in the evening), then you can just focus on the apples and let everything else fall away. I like doing the repetitive, menial things because I usually have a hard time focusing on one thing or committing to anything, so these kinds of tasks help ground me.

apple_chaider_pie-2       apple_chaider_pie-6

I haven’t tried the recipe with very many different types of apples yet, although I bought some green apples to make today’s pie, then decided it might not be so good with green apples. Someday, I’d like to go through a few iterations of the tart trying out different types of apples. Maybe even different types of black tea.

So much to do! So little money to buy the things to do the things I want to do (*cries publicly*).


And now, after three months of wading through pies and tarts and apple skins and dark rum, one would logically assume that I’ll be taking a break from pie for, like, a full year.

One would be wrong.

Now it’s time to work on some winter crumb tarts and gluten-free recipes. I tried gluten-free pie dough earlier and it was…so-so. It’s kind of a pain to work with because, due to a lack of gluten, it doesn’t hold together so you can’t pick it up, turn it, flip it, etc. You have to roll it out on parchment or wax paper and transfer it gently to the pie pan, then press it in. I was getting frustrated with the dough so I figured I could simplify everything by working on crumb crusts.

Call me in a month to see how they’re turning out.


This apple pie is unbelievable, y’all. The crust is finally flaky and buttery (thank you, Phoebe Lawless, the Pie Pastry Queen), the tea is lightly fragrant and the spices are rich, perfect for the season. The apples soften while the cider thickens, and the crispy streusel just floats around in all of it. It can be a little messy or runny, or it can hold up with integrity. At the workshop, Ms. Lawless mentioned that she likes to change recipes to cram in as many different flavors as possible, and when I saw a recipe for chai spiced apple pie online, I thought this would be a perfect opportunity to add one more flavor: buttery pie crust, spiced black tea, apples, and streusel.


apple chai-der pie with streusel topping

makes one 7-inch pie (with 9-in measurements in parentheses)


one 7-inch buttery pie crust, recipe here


45 g all-purpose flour (60 g)

30 g granulated sugar (45 g)

a dash of cinnamon (a dash and a half)

a pinch of salt (a pinch and a half)

1 ounce (2 T) unsalted butter (1.5 ounce/3 T)



250 – 300 g red apples (2 large apples) (350 – 450 g)

70 g granulated sugar (105 g)

20 g all-purpose flour (30 g)

1 tsp cinnamon (1 1/2 tsp)

1/2 tsp cardamom (3/4 tsp)

1 bag black tea, cut open (1 bag)

1/4 tsp each of ground ginger, black pepper, cloves, nutmeg (1/4 tsp)

a pinch of salt (a pinch and a half)

50 g apple cider (75 g)


prepare crust

Follow the recipe to make a disc of pie crust. The night before, or the morning of, baking, transfer dough from the freezer to the fridge, and when ready to roll out, take out of the fridge and let thaw on counter for 15 – 20 minutes before rolling.

Roll out on a liberally-floured surface, turning and flipping the disc as you go.

Lay dough into pie pan and crimp the edges. This doesn’t need any pre-baking so you can chill/freeze until everything else is ready.


make streusel

In a small food processor, blend together everything except the butter.

Slowly blend in the butter. If it clumps up, break clumps apart with your hands or a fork.

Chill until ready to use.


make filling

Peel, core, and chop the apples (quarter and slice, or chop however you like.)

Mix together sugar, flour, spices, salt, and loose tea in a small bowl.

Combine apples and dry mix in a large bowl, then pour in apple cider and mix.

You can either save the filling for later or fill the pie shell now. Let the filling pile up a few inches above the rim of the pan.

Dump the streusel on top of the unbaked pie.


You can freeze the whole pie assembled and unbaked.

When ready to bake, preheat the oven to 375 F/190 C.

Bake the pie for 50 – 60 minutes until the streusel and crust are browned and the filling is visibly bubbling.


Let cool and enjoy!


Happy Food, y’all!

Nick P.

Categories: pies and tarts, seasonal produce